* We omit melodies from our charts for copyright reasons.
"After You've Gone" is older than most tunes in the standard repertoire, and it plays like it. The chorus is only 20 bars instead of the usual 32, the harmony moves almost every measure, and it doesn't even start on the tonic. If you've been working mostly out of the Great American Songbook's 1930s-and-later material, this one's a useful detour into where a lot of that harmonic vocabulary came from.
Turner Layton wrote the music and Henry Creamer wrote the lyrics in 1918. Al Jolson introduced it to a vaudeville crowd at the Winter Garden Theater that same year, and within months several other artists had cut their own versions. Marion Harris's recording was the one that stuck, hitting number one for three weeks in 1919. It wasn't written for a show or a film. It's a standalone Tin Pan Alley song, often grouped with "St. Louis Blues" and "Indiana" as one of only three pre-1920s tunes that actually made the jump into the swing era.
Two versions get cited constantly. Bessie Smith cut it in 1927 with Fletcher Henderson on piano, bluesy and unhurried. Benny Goodman's Trio took it on in 1935 with Teddy Wilson on piano and Gene Krupa on drums, and it's brighter, tighter, and probably the version more pianists actually pull the changes from.
Want blues phrasing, go to Smith. Want the swing vocabulary, go to Goodman.
The big one: the tune opens on IV, not I. In Bb, that means you're sitting on Ebmaj7 before you ever hear the tonic, which is part of why it can feel disorienting the first few times through. From there it moves through a subdominant minor sound (that IVmaj7 to iv-minor6 shift) or a backdoor dominant back toward I, the same move you'll recognize from "Just Friends" and "I'll See You in My Dreams," which both open the same way.
Once you land on I, it doesn't stay long. The progression drops into a circle-of-fifths run of secondary dominants (VI7 to II7 to V7), and later in the form there's a ii-V of IV that cycles you back to the top. That's a lot of harmonic ground for 20 bars. Work it slowly with guide tones before you try to solo over it at tempo.
It's also a contrafact source: Art Pepper built "Straight Life" over these same changes, then named his autobiography after it.
Grab the chord chart above and play through the harmony slowly, tracking where the tonic actually resolves. Knowing the map matters more than usual here. The harmonic rhythm won't give you much room to guess.
By using Jazz-Library, you agree to our Cookies Policy.
